Democrats Scramble as Leaked Data Reveals Troubling Voter Turnout in Urban Areas Ahead of Election Day

November 4, 2024

With less than 24 hours until Election Day, the Democratic Party is reportedly facing significant challenges as leaked data reveals a troubling dip in voter turnout in urban areas across key battleground states. Traditionally, urban centers and early voting have been the backbone of Democratic support, but current data suggests that Vice President Kamala Harris’s campaign may struggle to close the gap with former President Donald Trump, who is leading in absentee and early voting turnout.

A memo from Tim Saler, Chief Data Consultant for the Republican National Committee, has highlighted a “massive turnout deficit” in Democratic strongholds, casting doubts on whether Harris can rally enough support on Election Day to offset these losses. According to Saler, urban turnout is down significantly, while rural turnout—a demographic favoring Trump—is up in nearly every battleground state.

Data Shows Worrying Trends for Democrats

Leaked data paints a challenging picture for the Harris campaign. In states where early voting has closed, the memo reveals a stark contrast between Democratic and Republican turnout. Urban turnout, typically a stronghold for Democrats, is down in states like Pennsylvania, Arizona, and Michigan. Additionally, female voter turnout, another key Democratic demographic, has also declined in several battleground states. Conversely, rural areas, which tend to favor Trump, have seen an increase in voter turnout.

Key Statistics from the Memo:

Arizona: Urban turnout is down by 385,285 votes compared to 2020, while rural turnout has increased by 14,124 votes.
Georgia: Urban turnout is down by 153,846 votes, but rural turnout is up by 171,837 votes.
Michigan: Urban turnout is down by 321,523 votes, and female turnout has decreased by 204,856 votes.
North Carolina: Urban turnout is down by 175,470 votes, and female turnout has declined by 154,459 votes.
Pennsylvania: Urban turnout is down by 381,519 votes, with female turnout seeing a significant drop of 450,802 votes.
Wisconsin: Urban turnout is down by 100,733 votes, and female turnout is down by 238,452 votes.

The leaked data underscores that Democrats are facing a substantial shortfall in key demographics and locations where they have historically relied on strong numbers.

Democrats Voice Concern, Urging Last-Minute Efforts

Several high-profile Democrats have voiced concerns over the turnout trends. Jim Messina, former campaign manager for President Obama, recently called the early voting numbers “a little scary” during an appearance on MSNBC. Political commentator David Axelrod, who was also a top Obama strategist, echoed these sentiments, saying, “There are no guarantees that voters will turn out on Election Day for Vice President Harris.”

Messina and Axelrod’s comments come amid calls from Democrats for an unprecedented Election Day turnout, which some analysts believe is a tall order. Historically, Democratic voters have leaned on early and absentee voting rather than Election Day turnout, which is more commonly favored by Republicans.

Republican Gains in Early and Absentee Voting

While the Democrats are grappling with turnout challenges, the Trump campaign is reporting gains in absentee and early voting, further boosting Republican confidence. According to an NBC News report, Trump holds a 16-point lead among voters who plan to cast their ballots on Election Day.

The memo underscores Trump’s position going into Election Day, calling it his strongest yet. As Eric Daugherty of the RNC shared on social media, “With early voting closed and Election Day on the horizon, Democrats are facing a massive turnout deficit… President Trump is going into Election Day stronger than he has in any previous election.”

Challenges in Pennsylvania: A Key Battleground

In Pennsylvania, a state expected to play a decisive role in the election, former Philadelphia Mayor Michael Nutter warned that Harris would need a 600,000-vote margin in Philadelphia alone to overtake Trump’s current lead in the state. This daunting task highlights the importance of urban turnout in Pennsylvania, a state where Trump’s rural base has shown strong engagement.

Comparisons to Past Elections and Future Implications

Political analysts are drawing comparisons between the 2024 election and the 2020 election, where high urban turnout and mail-in ballots were instrumental in securing Joe Biden’s victory. However, with urban and female turnout both lagging behind 2020 levels, Harris’s campaign faces significant challenges.

Even with strong polling numbers in major cities in past elections, a decline in turnout this year could suggest waning enthusiasm or increased voter apathy in Democratic strongholds. Additionally, this shortfall may reflect broader shifts in voter demographics and party allegiance, particularly among independent and moderate voters who may feel disillusioned.

Looking Ahead: Democrats’ Final Push

With Election Day just hours away, the Harris campaign is making a final push to engage urban voters and bring out support across key demographics. High-profile Democrats, including Harris herself, have been making last-minute campaign stops, urging voters to make their voices heard. The push for high voter turnout reflects the party’s awareness of the turnout gap and the potential implications for the election outcome.

As the clock ticks down, Democrats are hoping that efforts to drive Election Day turnout will prove successful, while Republicans are optimistic that early turnout trends reflect a shift in the electoral map. With urban turnout numbers lower than expected, the 2024 election could be one of the most closely contested in recent memory, with both parties relying on a last-minute surge to determine the winner.

Sources: